الطريق اللانهائي

2009 October 22

According to the State Department, I became fluent in Arabic two months ago. Yesterday, I accidentally convinced the first Saudi that I was Lebanese based on my language ability. But four months into working at the State Department I feel like I’m spinning my wheels and at best not losing ground with Arabic.


It could be that work occupies so much time and Arabic is a jealous mistress. I’m used to spending 50 hour weeks studying Arabic like I did in January. Now, those 50 hours go to the embassy, and I’m lucky if I study an hour a day.  Even though I’m using Arabic in interviews, I can’t push the boundaries of my knowledge like I did with intense study. Since coming to Riyadh, I’ve struggled to even review vocab for 15 minutes a day. So, I’m starting to forget vocab that I learned while in Damascus in May. Also disheartening, I have not finished a single book since coming to Riyadh a month ago compared to 5 for my three months in living in DC.

Spinning my Wheels

Also, the sense of success from passing an Arabic test for pay bonus has faded into pessimism about future progress. The State Department’s language institute always emphasizes that deep knowledge of a language takes orders of magnitude more time than superficial understanding. On average, progressing each additional level on the ILR scale takes as long as the combined time spent studying the language so far. So according to State guidelines, if it takes 3040 hours to go from nothing to a 3/3, it will take another 3040 hours to go from here to a 4/4. If I were to view the problem purely in terms of vocabulary, gaining appreciably more understanding of the language means learning thousands more obscure words, rather than hundreds. The good news is that I have a year in Saudi Arabia to absorb as much Arabic as I can. The bad news is that the path of learning has shifted from a sprint to a marathon.

5 Responses leave one →
  1. 2009 October 24
    Florence permalink

    Hi Jonathan,
    I stumbled over your blog today as I was doing some research for my Arabic. I am in a very similar situation, and know how hard it can be not to be able to see the light at the end of the tunnel. However, I know from other languages that I learned that at some point it stops being so f*ing hard and enlarging your vocabulary turns to fun. Don’t give up, there will be the day when you won’t even remember not speaking Arabic.

  2. 2009 October 28
    waz permalink

    just discovered your blog after getting distracted from lesson three in Pimsleur Eastern Arabic….. so I’m supremely jealous of your ‘disillusionment’ already. Please continue to post, you’re my inspiration! Cheers

  3. 2009 October 28
    waz permalink

    (and oh yeah – any thoughts on Pimsleur? you must have bumped into it at some point?)

  4. 2009 November 5

    Florence: I feel like I’ve gotten over the hump, but I suspect that the long tail of vocabulary in Arabic is more massive than other languages.

    Waz: I’ve used pimseleur a bit before I went to Damascus. I think it’s really good for meet and greet Arabic, but I wonder where a student would continue after finishing the 2 courses in Syrian? (Or Egyptian)

  5. 2010 February 15

    We should start up an Arabic support group for those who want to learn more, but have busy lives. I find myself in a similar place as I teach, with my free time absorbed by grading, etc.

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS